The problem is that ISDATE returns 0 for valid DATETIMEOFFSET values."
I couldn't believe it since Books Online until I tested it out myself
IF ISDATE('2009-09-08 10:19:41.177 -05:00') = 1
This returns INVALID when, in fact, it is a valid datetime value with time zone awareness. I even tried the values provided by Books Online and still gives me invalid results. I have yet to wait for a response from the SQL Server product group regarding this but at least it gives us an opportunity to dig deper